I read
A Deaf Blogger's Perspective's post about one of his biggest pet peeves: poor writing skills (found throughout various blogs on DeafRead). He made a good point about how essential it is to proofread what you wrote. If you want to be taken seriously, you have to be sure that what you wrote is clear and has little or no grammatical mistakes.
A blogger,
thumpaflash wrote about this and I think he made some good points:
From
Deaf and Unemployed:
'There is also still the question of many who question WHY they need to write or communicate well with English. I'm here to tell you now, as both a former hiring manager AND as a current prospective employee, proper communication skills in the written vernacular are essential. I have seen MANY jobs listed as seeking candidates in my field (loss prevention, safety, security, investigations), and I have also seen MANY of these postings with grammatical errors, spelling errors, etc. So poor English skills are NOT limited to the deaf or hard of hearing, don't get me wrong, but when I read blogs and comments as I peruse through the DeafRead postings and so forth, I cringe. Call me a deaf audist if you want. Say I look down my nose at others in the deaf community if you wish ( I do not), but the fact remains, good communication skills are essential. Almost every position I have seen the requirements posted for have had a requirement posted that states something along these lines: "Must have excellent oral OR written communication skills".'
Now, I am fully aware that many hearing people, even professional writers, will write poorly with plenty of grammatical mistakes.
I am also aware that I have made plenty of errors in my writing and I will make many more. But, I do make the effort to proofread and to correct my mistakes if I catch any. I often write spontaneously and out of excitement which is part of the reason why my writing is not so great here. If this was a term paper or some sort of writing test, my writing would be a lot more professional and 'more better'.
However, I would like to think that my writing here is often clear and effective, and will hopefully be taken seriously by others.
But, I will say this. There are times where I will read a certain deaf person's blog which is always full of errors, but I usually understand what he is trying to say and I will take him seriously. I am trying to be sensitive to the fact that ASL is his first language (after years of not having much of a language growing up oral). He clearly did not have access to fluent language growing up (which clearly was not the best communication mode for him at the time, or he was not taught properly).
Ok, so
A Deaf Blogger's Perspective's blog post reminded me of situations I have had with some of my students in terms of their writing.
One of them was a profoundly deaf sixth grader who wore a cochlear implant (with it on, it appeared he had mild-moderate deafness in his right ear, and profound deafness in his left ear, (like me!)). At the time, he communicated in ASL and used an interpreter. His was fluent in ASL and was able to communicate with those who use sign language. However, when it came to him speaking or writing he had a lot of difficulties. His writing made little sense. His word order often resembled choppy ASL grammatical order, and a lot of times his writing exhibited subject-verb agreement errors. In other words, his writing was TERRIBLE. He would not be able to communicate with others using a pen and paper if he had to. His speech was very hard to understand as well (I don't know why, could be due to an undiagnosed speech disorder). It was obvious that his cochlear implant did not work for him at all.
So, his writing was terrible, yet he made A's and B's in all of his classes. If this continues, this could mean that he will graduate from high school never learning how to write clear complete sentences. It seemed as if no one really worked with him on his writing (just an assumption). How is it that he made it to sixth grade without ever knowing how to write clear complete sentences about simple things? When I asked him to write two sentences using the word
rock, he wrote, "a rock is from material. a rock is a music." When I asked him to write about swimming in the pool he wrote, "I Like jump on Pool. I splash a water. water is start splash." What??!! How the hell did he make it to sixth grade with this kind of writing?!
I have learned that there are plenty of students (hearing and deaf) who often get by without ever learning how to write. Unbelievable! You may not know how to write or read, but as long as you make good grades, you are fine. I learned that if the teacher is not grading the quality of writing, the student can make a decent grade. For example, let's say my student knew the answer to a problem (which he often did) and needed to write a paragraph about it. Even if it was written very poorly, if the science teacher can see what he meant by it and if he answered correctly, she can give him a good grade. But, how did he pass his English and Language Arts classes? I have to wonder.
I had to really work with him on his writing. He was finally starting to get somewhere with his writing when he had to move to another school.
It angers me that his inability to write followed him to the sixth grade. What happened?
His interpreter told me that I needed to be sensitive to the fact that ASL is his first language. I'm sorry, but being sensitive to his deafness is not going to cut it. I can't use it as an excuse to not push him to learn to write. He is still very young and we have time. This should have been addressed a long time ago! Perhaps he has some undiagnosed disorder which is affecting his writing skills. I blame most of it on his parents and teachers. I would get so mad when I ask some of his teachers how he is doing. They always beamed, "Oh, he is doing great. He made an A on his test! Making great grades!" No one said anything about his writing. I never heard from his parents, even though I left several messages with them.
I wholeheartedly believe that we cannot use deafness or any type of disability as an excuse for poor writing skills with young people. Now, I do sympathize with those who grew up in the wrong environment (wrong communication choice, bad schools, bad teachers, bad parents, poor role models, etc.). For those who are severely-profoundly deaf, I can't imagine what it must have been like to have gone through elementary, junior high, and high school, not being properly taught to read and write. I bet for some of you, most of the emphasis was on speech and making good grades.
So, I don't blame those who are deaf with poor writing skills and I don't mean to rub it in your faces. Writing is very hard. It is not your fault, I know the education system failed you, and I am truly sorry for that! I don't know how one would begin in order to improve in writing. Just keep writing and please make the effort to proofread. Have your friends proofread it. This would be the best way to learn and practice. Also, read every chance you get. Pay attention to what you are reading (how it is written) and learn from it.
Overall, if you want to be taken seriously, you must learn to write properly. Now, if you want to be rich and famous you do not necessarily HAVE to write and read 'real good'---just look at
Paris Hilton and the
Jersey Shore cast.
(e
I highly recommend this book, for help with writing: