I really like this quote by Albert Einstein:
“You have to learn the rules of the game. And then you have to play better than anyone else.”
It is very important that you learn the "rules of the game" if you want to be successful. No matter where you are, you usually indirectly and directly learn or are taught the "rules of the game" through experiencing everyday customs and manners that are traditionally practiced by most in the culture you grow up in. For example, in America, it is expected that you have a good command of the English language, work hard, and not complain too much if you want to be successful in conventional society. In most areas of the United States, it also helps to be up to date with the latest news, gossip, celebrities, television shows, or movies.
However, it does not mean that you have to be like everyone else or do the exactly the same things other successful people are doing. I believe that once you have a full understanding of the rules of the game, you can have the power to play better, challenge the rules of the game, or to change them.
My high school art teacher once gave me very good advice:
"Before you can paint whatever you like in however fashion you like, you must first learn the basics and the traditional rules of art."
So, this is where the idea of mainstreaming comes in. One of the goals of mainstreaming is to give students with special needs the chance to integrate with the general population while receiving the same type of education. Many hope that with mainstreaming, the students with special needs will effectively learn the rules of the game played by the general population.
I do agree with the notion that by being surrounded by the general population you will pick up naturally how to socialize and interact with others appropriately. For example, I think it is a terrible idea to place a student with behavioral issues into a class where everyone else has behavioral issues. How is this child supposed to learn how to behave appropriately or learn what is supposed to be typical behavior?
When it comes to the deaf or hard of hearing child it is different.
I feel that some deaf and hard of hearing children with the inability to communicate with others naturally is going to have a hard time in a mainstreamed environment. Perhaps there are ways to help these certain students, but throwing them into a general education classroom and leaving them without much support and equal access to information and communication is most likely not the answer.
How are some deaf and hard of hearing students supposed to learn the rules of the game if they do not have equal access to the information they need to know? How are they supposed to learn the rules of the game if they are emotionally or socially stunted due to a lack of natural communication with their peers? How are these students supposed to learn if their family members are reluctant to make the effort to interact and communicate with them at home?
For example, what about the deaf or hard of hearing child who will regularly miss what is being said in side conversations, in jokes being told, within a group of people socializing, from the radio, or from non-captioned videos or television programs being shown in class or at home?
What about the student with the interpreter by her side at all times, making it awkward for her to interact with some students?
What about the student who is always behind in class because he or she regularly misses what is being said because the teacher is going too fast or because of constant background noises?
Most people learn the rules of the game through school, social interactions, casual conversations, watching television, watching movies, and listening to the radio.
How do we provide mainstreamed deaf and hard of hearing students equal access to all of these things that typically hearing students take for granted?
Mainstreaming is not perfect, but I believe we can make it work. There has to be a way to make it work.
It is important that we look at and try to understand the difficult issues some mainstreamed deaf and hard of hearing students may face before we can make the necessary changes. If we truly want them to be mainstreamed or part of the general population we must make it easier for them to access the information they need in order to learn how to be productive members of general society.
I am working on it.
But, first I must learn the rules of the game played by this public school district. Then, hopefully, I will be able to play better than everyone else for the sake of these students.
(e
“You have to learn the rules of the game. And then you have to play better than anyone else.”
It is very important that you learn the "rules of the game" if you want to be successful. No matter where you are, you usually indirectly and directly learn or are taught the "rules of the game" through experiencing everyday customs and manners that are traditionally practiced by most in the culture you grow up in. For example, in America, it is expected that you have a good command of the English language, work hard, and not complain too much if you want to be successful in conventional society. In most areas of the United States, it also helps to be up to date with the latest news, gossip, celebrities, television shows, or movies.
However, it does not mean that you have to be like everyone else or do the exactly the same things other successful people are doing. I believe that once you have a full understanding of the rules of the game, you can have the power to play better, challenge the rules of the game, or to change them.
My high school art teacher once gave me very good advice:
"Before you can paint whatever you like in however fashion you like, you must first learn the basics and the traditional rules of art."
So, this is where the idea of mainstreaming comes in. One of the goals of mainstreaming is to give students with special needs the chance to integrate with the general population while receiving the same type of education. Many hope that with mainstreaming, the students with special needs will effectively learn the rules of the game played by the general population.
I do agree with the notion that by being surrounded by the general population you will pick up naturally how to socialize and interact with others appropriately. For example, I think it is a terrible idea to place a student with behavioral issues into a class where everyone else has behavioral issues. How is this child supposed to learn how to behave appropriately or learn what is supposed to be typical behavior?
When it comes to the deaf or hard of hearing child it is different.
I feel that some deaf and hard of hearing children with the inability to communicate with others naturally is going to have a hard time in a mainstreamed environment. Perhaps there are ways to help these certain students, but throwing them into a general education classroom and leaving them without much support and equal access to information and communication is most likely not the answer.
How are some deaf and hard of hearing students supposed to learn the rules of the game if they do not have equal access to the information they need to know? How are they supposed to learn the rules of the game if they are emotionally or socially stunted due to a lack of natural communication with their peers? How are these students supposed to learn if their family members are reluctant to make the effort to interact and communicate with them at home?
For example, what about the deaf or hard of hearing child who will regularly miss what is being said in side conversations, in jokes being told, within a group of people socializing, from the radio, or from non-captioned videos or television programs being shown in class or at home?
What about the student with the interpreter by her side at all times, making it awkward for her to interact with some students?
What about the student who is always behind in class because he or she regularly misses what is being said because the teacher is going too fast or because of constant background noises?
Most people learn the rules of the game through school, social interactions, casual conversations, watching television, watching movies, and listening to the radio.
How do we provide mainstreamed deaf and hard of hearing students equal access to all of these things that typically hearing students take for granted?
Mainstreaming is not perfect, but I believe we can make it work. There has to be a way to make it work.
It is important that we look at and try to understand the difficult issues some mainstreamed deaf and hard of hearing students may face before we can make the necessary changes. If we truly want them to be mainstreamed or part of the general population we must make it easier for them to access the information they need in order to learn how to be productive members of general society.
I am working on it.
But, first I must learn the rules of the game played by this public school district. Then, hopefully, I will be able to play better than everyone else for the sake of these students.
(e
Thank you for writing this. Mainstreaming is not a clear-cut solution for some students with hearing loss. Sending them to the state school isn't a clear-cut answer, either.
ReplyDeleteOne idea is to cluster them at the high school level. Often times, in a rural school district, it would mean just one high school. And have just one dedicated class just for those students manned by a credentialed Teacher of the Deaf. This class can be an elective, focusing on standardized testing strategies, or be a core class, i.e., English, Reading, Algebra...
Hopefully other interesting ideas will come about! An 'ASL Club' meeting once a week after school, while an attractive option, can be potentially unfeasible due to transportation issues.
Thank you for your thoughts on this, Todd. I like your idea about clustering them at a high school level.
ReplyDeleteI always dream of starting after school 'Sign Language' clubs or Deaf/HH Scrabble or Chess clubs where they compete against each other. But, the reality of this happening right now is slim to none, unless some changes can be made.
Your comment reminded me of a blog entry I made;
ReplyDeleteSocio-Cultural Field Trips
Cluster schools, while nice, are slowly fading out of the picture as more and more students with hearing loss are mainstreamed at their 'home' schools. So, it's no panacea, either.
However, and I don't know about your school district; but maybe you can consider the possibility of 'sponsoring' a district-wide field trip for all students with hearing loss? The only caveat is that parents will have to transport their children, as they would be in their home schools. The actual field trip itself would be chaperoned by you and other personnel, i.e., interpreters, ToD's...
I'll give out a specific example that's used in my school district; we have a theater that gives out interpreted performances for 4 different plays throughout the school year. On those dates, it's a district-wide field trip for *all* students with hearing loss. The theater does provide transportation for cluster schools, but parents provide transportation for those who are mainstreamed in their home schools. I'm not sure of the specifics, but I think the theater secured a grant for this purpose.
So, in your district, you could find a cultural or arts event that you think would provide 'educational value'. (My school district requires this. I'd hate to see the actual 'educational value' proposed for the Santa Claus field trip!) You contact the venue, and explore the possibilities of sponsoring a field trip. It may turn out that they already have a grant and can help you out...
Then you recruit a couple of volunteers, i.e., interpreters, parent volunteers, etc. to handle the logistics, accessibility, and chaperoning the field trip. Then you submit a district-wide field trip proposal to the powers that be that are in your school district and hope for the best. :) I know, it's easier said than done...
This could be done once a year or twice a year, at different venues each time. (Variety is the spice of life...) Some students with hearing loss will participate, some will not, etc. just like what happens at our district-wide field trips. But, the main gist is that students with hearing loss will get together at one venue, interact with each other, and learn about something cultural. (Hey, there has to be some dint of educational value, after all!)
Oh- I did experience some 'blowback' about socio-cultural field trips. One teacher made a snide, almost passing, comment about the dubious nature of these field trips, complaining that the student is going on too many of these trips. I was quick to pick up on it, though, and decided to write a blog entry about it.
Good luck! I'm glad the students with hearing loss have a teacher like you in their school district.
Thank you Todd!! I think the district wide field trip is a fantastic idea! It would be so much fun and beneficial for these students. I will propose this idea and see if it would be possible to do one this year.
ReplyDeleteThank you Todd, and I am glad the students with hearing loss have a teacher like you in their school district. :)
Oh-
ReplyDeleteForgot to mention one thing; on these district-wide field trips, it was well attended by students at 'cluster' schools, as transportation was provided. That wasn't the case for mainstreamed students at their home schools, proving that transportation issues would still have to be settled somehow.
I would suggest that if you want to go through this route, do a preliminary survey first. I know, some parents won't reply, some will, and some will even offer help/feedback, etc. This way, you will know if it's worth your while.
And let's hope other readers of this blog will come up with ideas! Maybe I could use a few on my end.
Yes, deaf people should meet at least twice a month doing different actitivities (scrabble, field trips, etc.) some of them probably dont mind free basic sign language classes if it is not offered where they live . After all, this club may be very diverse in communication method and you want them to communicate with each other. I would have the club located at central point from where majority of deaf people live. People can ride with other people if they have to.
ReplyDeleteI am reminded I attended an Partial hearing unit in mainstream, being pretty avid at pushing my own cause (!), when I went to a mainstream business studies course, 'group' working was the norm, naturally I posed an immediate issue to the 'group' being a sole deaf person there, and I found fellow students willing to make effort to ensure I was included, however, the TEACHER called a halt to that and my further participation in the course, insisting I was 'slowing down progress for others...'. In reality I was widening the awareness of future business people, in including deaf people,and their skills in communications, surely, an important part for a business executive ? to no avail, I was asked to drop the coursework ! Take in to account I HAD no class support either. Late deafened are worse off than deaf kids... Had I no confidence in myself, I would not have been able to utilise further education at all.
ReplyDeleteMM- I am so sorry about the JERK who called him or herself a teacher. I can't believe they asked you to drop the class! Talk about blatant discrimination.
ReplyDeleteCome to think of it, You should start an upward bound and invite many deaf to join: http://www2.ed.gov/programs/trioupbound/index.html
ReplyDeleteI love this post... and I agree. I'm a deaf student that went entirely mainstream and based on my experience --- here is my opinion to contribute to your research as you reach for that goal: ***allowing more necessary work and learning experiences to be accessed from different avenues: written (ex:transcripts of lectures or pre-written lectures) and verbal*** I found that reading lectures while attending college online for a certain period -- it was helpful from the lecturing aspect. That's ALOT of work for a teacher -- however, if the school system is changed to fit different types of learning it may not be perfect but an improvement is better than none at all.
ReplyDeleteSocial interaction was a bit of a problem in my case: I've gone through the same experiences you've listed - being in group conversations and missing a joke or missing a glance at their lips(lipreader) when a noise can easily distract me. Luckily, I participated in afterschool activities of small groups that allowed people to get to know me better. I am 24, and over the past year, I've been introduced to and spent some time with the deaf community in my area. It's foreign to me sometimes because many of them SPEAK in "sign language"... and I was a little bothered because I really wish we could "bridge the gaps between hearing and deaf communities" -- it would be easier if we understood one another and are able to communicate properly. (Which is what my organization "Silent Echo of Harmony" is all about -- google us -- we're on Twitter) With that being said.... I like Todd's ideas especially these two: Clustering them at high school level and having ASL clubs or events/field trips for them so they can have "deaf support" and still have the tools & knowledge they need to play by the rules.
Thanks Anony, I will check out the link to 'upward bound'. Great information there. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteLaketa, thank you for your thoughts on this. It is great to hear from someone who actually experienced being mainstreamed as a deaf student recently. I can't wait to check out your organization! That is awesome that you were inspired to try to do something about some of the issues you come across. :)