For and Against HB 1367

I have been reading various blogs about the House Bill 1367 which proposes to "remove the outreach center currently housed at the Indiana School for the Deaf, terminate all staff working in that center, and recreate a new outreach center separate from the school" (from NAD's Action Alert: Support Ind.School for the Deaf, Oppose HB 1367). Many people online oppose this bill, while few support it. People in favor of communicating with sign language seem to be against it, while those who use auditory/oral means seem to support the bill.

I personally don't really have any strong opinions on the matter. I have never been to the school and the outreach center. I have not heard from or met anyone who personally visited the outreach center and receive services from them.  From looking at their website, they offer several different services and support in various areas (speech and language, audiology, IEPs, working with mainstreamed students, Deaf Role Model, education, literacy coach, assessment services, etc.). Seems like a great place for parents and caregivers to get information and help.

I guess it would be more cost effective to keep the center and just add to it, whatever services the outreach center may be lacking. It is nice that the center is located on campus. I can see why some people are upset by this bill. There are concerns that ISD would have no control over what happens in the center and that it will eventually focus mostly on auditory/oral approaches since HEAR INDIANA will apparently be a part of the new outreach center.

However, since ISD students are entitled to free appropriate education, the center could provide services and information on all communication modes such as cued speech and AVT. I did not see anywhere on their website that discusses or provides information about these two. So, I can also see why some support this bill, because they would like to see more auditory/oral information and services offered for free.

Before forming your own opinions on the matter, unless you know about the situation first hand (have visited the outreach center and school, met people who work there, met people who use their services, etc.) it is important to actually read the bill, look at both sides and try to understand where each side is coming from.

Below are some links to bloggers and organizations against the bill:

• NAD's Action Alert: Support Ind. School for the Deaf, Oppose HB 1367

• An Open Letter to Indiana Government

• Letter From ASDC Board about HB 1367

Here are some links (not many out there) to bloggers and organizations supporting the bill:

• Support Indiana HB 1367: All Options for Children With Hearing Loss

• Hear Indiana SUPPORT Deaf and Hard of Hearing Education (HB 1367)

We'll have to see what happens. But, in the end, whether a new center is built or not, parents and caregivers are still ultimately responsible for their children and learning about what they can do to support their children. There are no excuses in this day and age with easy and instant internet access to information about deaf and hard of hearing children, education, and communication modes. It is a daunting task, to weed through the information provided, no doubt. But, people should know better than to rely on only one or two sources of information. The information is out there on the internet, from various centers, schools, specialists, educators, deaf and hard of hearing people, and organizations. Do your research. Knowledge is power.

(e

Questions For Deaf & HOH Teachers From a Reader

A reader left a comment with questions in response to an earlier post, Deaf Student Teacher With Hearing Students. Perhaps some of you can answer her questions and give her suggestions.

Wow, this is a very inspiring article and I enjoy reading all your comments. I am currently a hearing impaired student teacher (hard of hearing) teaching hearing students. I've taught 5th grade hearing students and loved it. I wish I could speak to each and every one of you. I would like to know what strategies you use in the classroom when working with hearing children. (read more)

She left her email address in case any of you would like to contact her. Go to comments section under original posting to view it.

(e

Please Link Back!!

If you are going to include some or all I have written or posted here on your website or blog, please, please, please, provide a link back and give me some credit!

Feel free to do whatever you want with what I have written, just link back. It's not cool when someone takes what I wrote or posted on this blog and then re-post it or use parts of it on their blog and website and not give me any credit whatsoever.

What if There is a Cure For Deafness?

I am excited and fascinated by the news of stem cell research approved by FDA in relation to treating hearing loss. I can't wait to find out what they learn.

In light of the news, I have been asked by more and more people, "What if deafness was cured tomorrow? What would you do? Would you be upset about not working in deaf education?" I usually laugh and tell them, "I would not be upset. I would be excited for those who benefit from getting their hearing restored. But, in reality, not everyone will benefit from this procedure or will want to. There will still be deaf or hard of hearing students to work with. There will still be people with cochlear implants. Even if everyone magically becomes hearing overnight and there are no deaf people, there will still be people with communication issues who could benefit from accommodations and services which I can help provide. I would just have to change my job title I suppose."

I think it would be incredibly selfish of me to be upset by the idea of a cure for deafness, because I will no longer be a teacher of the deaf. I would be thrilled if my students and their families no longer have to deal with communication issues, accommodations, special education, IEPs, small group, inclusion, speech therapy, hearing aids, cochlear implants, constantly being left out of most everyday spoken conversations, etc.

When people talk to me about cures for deafness and how it will happen any day now, I imagine truckloads of deaf and hard of hearing people lining up to receive their magical ear drops and suddenly have the ability to typically hear.

I don't think it will be this easy, as least not so soon.

Nevertheless, I can't wait to hear what they learn. How exciting!

(e

Crap People Say to Teachers of the Deaf & HOH

• "Wow, how sweet of you!"

• "You teach deaf kids? How noble of you."

• "You work on their speech and stuff?" 

• "Oh, like a speech teacher." 

•  "Must be nice having quiet students." 

• "Why do deaf people [insert question]?"

• "Aren't you concerned that sign language will keep the student from talking?" 

• "Since you work with him on speech, do you have any suggestions on how he can improve his articulation errors?" 

• "How do you teach deaf students to talk?" 

• "Can you interpret?" [for something that requires a certified sign language interpreter, like a formal evaluation/interview with a deaf signing student].

• "This is the speech teacher." 

• "Do you work on other things beside speech?"  

  (e

Crap Hearing People Say to Deaf & HOH People

A YouTube video that has gone viral inspired me to write about the ignorant and funny comments some people make to deaf and hard of hearing people. The video I am talking about is by comedian Franchesca Ramsey. She recently uploaded a YouTube video S**t White Girls Say to Black Girls. Apparently, she was inspired by another YouTube video S**t Girls Say. The video is controversial and some people do not find it funny. I thought it was a pretty hilarious and interesting social commentary. I think what makes some people upset about it is that it makes them think and honestly evaluate themselves. Sometimes it can be hard to cast a critical eye on yourself. 

Too bad the video is not captioned! Because I don't want my fellow deaf and hard of hearing readers to be completely left out, I provided some of the dialogue that I am able to understand. If anyone, who can hear everything she said, would like to provide a transcript for the video, please feel free! That would be great. I would provide a full transcript, but it would not be very accurate, being that I'm hard of hearing and all. Sorry.

Partial transcript (some of the dialogue that I could hear):

"Not to be racist, but. . ."

"My grandma hates collards. Wait, is that racist?"

"Why isn't there a White Entertainment Television?" 

"You can say the N word, but I can't? How is that okay?"

"My best friend was black. I mean, she's still black [unintelligible mumbling]".

"Why is this computer acting so ghetto?"

(Pointing to painted black figures) "That one kind of looks like you, right?"  

"Girlfriend!" 

"Hollah!" 

"I think what I like most about them is that they're not stereotypical like black people. You know what I mean?" 

"It's almost like you're not black."  


You get the idea.

Instead of making a video (I got lazy and could not find anyone who wanted to participate), I will write out some of the things I have actually heard people say to deaf and hard of hearing people, including me. For the record, I don't think all people with typical hearing will make these comments. I can understand why some of the following comments were made. However, I can't help but laugh at some of them for being unbelievably stupid and rude.

Crap Hearing People Say to Deaf and Hard of Hearing People:

• "Wow, I never would have known you are deaf!" 

• "You don't look deaf."

• "She was so beautiful, you would have not known she was deaf." 

• "What's reading braille like?" 

• "Can you have children?"

• "You speak so well!" 

• "You don't sound like a deaf person." 

• "What? There's no need for captions. Here, I'll turn up the volume, I don't mind." (turns up volume on t.v. really loud, smiles and gives the thumbs up).

• "Oh, never mind. I'll tell you later."

• "Turn up your hearing aid!"

• "Why don't deaf people just get cochlear implants?"

• "Oh, I love sign language! "A. . . . .B. . . . .C. . ."

• "Why don't you ever listen to me?" 

• "I bet you are just pretending to be deaf, huh?"

•  "What is your problem? You were hearing me fine just a second ago. Are you listening?" 

• "Oh, he's probably not deaf. Selective hearing, right?" (laughs)

• "GEEZ! I. . .SAID. . . WHAT. . .DO. . .YOU. . .WANT. . .TO. . .DO?!!!"  

•  "Doesn't it make you sad that you won't hear your child say, "I love you."?

•  "Can you read their lips and tell me what they are saying?" 

• "Oh, how do you sign @#%^, *#$%, %@!*&, and !@@#$%& ? 

•  "Can you hear me now?" (laughs)

•  "You don't need an interpreter. We can understand what you are saying."

• "Oh, you are deaf? Like Helen Keller! Cool!" 

• "Gosh, you deaf people are so angry and militant!" 

• (Whispers) "Look! He has a hearing aid, just like you!" (points)

• "Didn't you hear? Oh- Eer, um. . .so sorry, um." (laughs nervously)

• "Oh, you're deaf? Sorry." 

(e